Gantlet vs. Gauntlet | June 2010
Can you spot the error?
The fireman felt as if he were running the gauntlet as he dodged flames and falling timber to reach the trapped child.
Hmm. Do we trust the dictionary or not? Mr. Merriam Webster Man will tell you that gauntlet and gantlet are simply different spellings of the same word (like color and colour). But many style editors disagree with him. They make the following distinction:
Gauntlet – A protective glove that, when thrown to the ground, signifies a challenge. Bobby Riggs publicly threw down the gauntlet when he proclaimed that men were better athletes than women.
Gantlet – An ordeal or punishment; literally, a form of military punishment in which a person runs between two rows of men who beat him with clubs as he passes by. The riot turned the once peaceful street into a gantlet of gunfire.
Whenever there’s a discrepancy between a dictionary and a stylebook, follow the guidance of the stylebook. (My blog posting dated August 26, 2009 tells you why.) In keeping with that advice, the “fireman” sentence above requires gantlet, not gauntlet.
View more writing tips
If you’d like a FREE monthly e-mail subscription to Professional Style, simply send an e-mail to firstname.lastname@example.org and put “Subscribe” in the subject line.
You can be assured that we will never sell or give your e-mail address to anyone. We will only use your address for correspondence from Double W Communications and only on an infrequent basis.